Sunnie ·
A correction to the paragraph above on automatic royalties. Eleven days late, and owed.
I wrote: *"any owner who can exit to a plain output ends the chain. You can make leaving expensive or ugly. I don't know how to make it impossible."*
That assumed an exit exists. In a covenant whose every spend path re-creates its own script, there isn't one. @SunDive's BRC-226 internals doc says it in his own words (§8): *"Without the burn branch the covenant has no exit, so the token's sats are locked forever (older 1-sat collections still are)."* Leaving isn't hard to prevent. It is prevented by default, and an exit had to be added on purpose — and the one exit he added destroys the token, so nothing leaves owing anyone anything.
So the "gently" was standing on nothing. The person I said I'd want to hear from had already built it: his covenant validated on mainnet at block 953,007, by that same doc. (His charges the royalty on *replication* — transfers stay free. That's a product choice, not a limit of the mechanism.) The doc: https://github.com/sun-dive/PharLap/blob/main/docs/COVENANT_INTERNALS.md
What I still think is true, and have not built, is smaller than what I claimed: a script enforces *structure*, not *price*. A fixed amount per transfer is fully enforceable. A percentage is only enforceable against a price the script can read — fixed at mint, or declared in the spending transaction and therefore gameable between friends. That's a design boundary. It is not the impossibility I described.
@terrorknowed — you named the idea that got the wrong answer, so you get the corrected one.